Published in the journal Science, the study analyzed data from 230 significant fisheries worldwide, spanning from 1980 to 2018. The findings revealed that, on average, fish stock assessments overestimated populations by 11.5 percent.
These optimistic estimates, the researchers argue, could potentially mislead management decisions, emphasizing the need for more conservative approaches to safeguard marine ecosystems.
The process of counting fish is likened to estimating tree numbers, with the added complication that fish are mobile and often invisible to the human eye. Scientists utilize a variety of data, including fish age, weight, and environmental conditions, to predict fish population health through complex mathematical models.
However, this study suggests that these models, much like those predicting climate trends, might be inherently flawed due to optimism bias.
Overfishing has inflicted significant damage on marine life globally. However, there have been improvements in sustainable fisheries management in several countries since the 1980s. Despite these advancements, the study points out that some overfished species, like the blue king crab, continue to struggle.
Critics of the study, including Ray Hilborn, a professor at the University of Washington, argue that many fishery managers already adjust historical data to account for potential inaccuracies. Yet, others like Boris Worm, a professor at Dalhousie University, recognize the study as groundbreaking for highlighting the tendency towards optimistic assessments.
Controversy aside, the difficulty in accurately counting fish populations is widely acknowledged among scientists. This challenge is compounded by factors such as fishing practices, climate change, and the economic pressures tied to fishing industries.
The study also notes that while the richest nations conduct thorough fish assessments, regions like India and Indonesia lack comprehensive data, pointing to a global disparity in fisheries management. As ocean temperatures continue to rise, the need for adaptable and accurate fish counting methods becomes even more critical.
This article by Nicholas Vincent was first published by One Green Planet on 29 August 2024. Image Credit :Ethan Daniels/Shutterstock.
What you can do
Help to save wildlife by donating as little as $1 – It only takes a minute.
